Sign up for our Free email Newsletter
and get all the latest wildlife news!
Choose:

Welsh Assembly relaunches badger cull

09/03/2011 12:18:40 A dead end policy in every respect, say RSPCA

March 2011. The Welsh Assembly Government have confirmed that it will be carrying out a badger cull in North Pembrokeshire as part of a package of measures which aim to tackle the problem of bovine TB in cattle. The RSPCA is deeply disappointed to learn that contentious plans for a badger cull in Wales have been given the go ahead. This cull could lead to the virtual elimination of badgers from an area of nearly 300 km2

Previous plans for a cull were dismissed by the Court of Appeal last July after the Badger Trust won a legal challenge to stop it. The Welsh government put forward revised, but similar, proposals shortly afterwards for a cull in a specified area in the corner of the country most affected by the disease. It has now announced that these will go ahead.

The RSPCA has always been firmly opposed to the proposed cull in Wales. They believe that vaccination, increased levels of testing, improved biosecurity and stricter controls on the movement of cattle are more sustainable and effective ways of reducing the incidence of bovine TB in cattle.

Senior wildlife scientist Colin Booty said: ""The RSPCA is saddened to hear that the Welsh government has decided to go down the road of a cull after all. We believe that this is a dead end policy in every respect. Not only will it result in the death of at least 70% of badgers from the cull area, but it will not resolve the problem in other areas of Wales.

"Geographical features which exist in the Pembrokeshire area mean that such a policy cannot be rolled out for use elsewhere in all the TB affected areas of Wales. In addition, The Independent Scientific Group* concluded that the elimination of badgers across large areas was not a feasible control option.

"A couple of thousand badgers will be killed and the attempt to find a solution to bovine TB in cattle in Wales will still be at a dead-end."

The Independent Scientific Group on cattle TB (ISG)

The Independent Scientific Group on cattle TB (ISG) examined the science behind a badger cull. It published its final report in 2007 which was the result of painstaking research over nearly ten years, took the lives of about 11,000 badgers and cost taxpayers £50 million. It concluded that killing badgers could actually increase the spread of bTB, making matters worse rather than better. It said, "badger culling can make no meaningful contribution to cattle TB control in Britain" 
Click here to see the report

cull area

At 288 km2 "The cull area proposed for the Welsh cull is nearly three times the size of the areas culled in the ISG trials in England and it is therefore difficult to envisage how culling might be carried out in accordance with all the criteria set out by the Independent Scientific Group. For example, how would simultaneous culling be achieved over such a large area?

Read the comments about this article and leave your own comment

Wales is NOT Badger friendly

Why isn't there an initiative to have produce marked "Badger Friendly" which marking can be extended or withdrawn depending on whether there are lazy but very rich farmers who practise poor animal husbandry and try for a quick fix by killing wildlife- badgers and raptors (always at the taxpayers' expense) or hard working farmers producing quality produce in sympathy with the surrounding coutryside and more in accord with modern British values and ancient Welsh ones.
NZ has bovine TB but no badgers. These Welsh farmers would probably import badgers into NZ for the perpertuation of blame and kill cuture just as their forefathers did in N America with Red Foxes.
We should boycott Welsh produce and tourism. See which they prefer for their national image -hard working with a popular humanitarian culture, or an impoverished barbaric backwater of tax guzzlers!

Posted by: Clive Freemantle | 12 Mar 2011 10:04:01

To post a comment you must be logged in.
CLICK HERE TO LOG IN AND POST A COMMENT

New user? Register here

 

Click join and we will email you with your password. You can then sign on and join the discussions right away.